Matei Clej Succeeds in Extradition Appeal: Defective Warrant Cannot Be Cured by Further Information
A warrant silent on the convictions underlying half of the sentence could not be rescued by a bare reference to the Criminal Code.
Mocanu v Mizil Court of First Instance (Romania) [2026] EWHC 2937 (Admin)

On 13 November 2026 Mr Justice Kimblin allowed Mr Mocanu’s appeal, discharged him and quashed the extradition order. The warrant sought his return to serve three years for driving without a licence and using a forged licence, both in June 2021. Further information revealed that the term included sentences for convictions in 2019 and 2024, neither mentioned in the warrant; eighteen months derived from the 2019 conviction alone. The only trace on the face of the warrant was the phrase "with the application of Article 41 (1) of the Criminal Code", the Code’s post-conviction relapse provision.
The defect was not new. The earlier, withdrawn warrant stated "1 offence" and a resulting penalty of 2 years, 3 months and 10 days, which already incorporated the 2019 sentence without mentioning it. Nor did the further information arise from the warrant: the first request followed only after the defence served Romanian court portal extracts disclosing the aggregation.
Three points emerge from the judgment.
First, validity is tested within the four corners of the warrant. It was common ground that the further information was accurate and, if admissible, sufficient. That did not help the Respondent: where the failure is wholesale, further information would be "writing the important details of the warrant afresh" (at [44]), and admitting it would itself offend mutual cooperation (Podolak v Poland [2020] EWHC 2830 (Admin) at [19], applying Alexander v France [2017] EWHC 1392 (Admin)).
Second, a bare reference to a relapse or recidivism provision is an insufficient signal to prompt further inquiry. The mention of Article 41(1) indicated only that the offence was committed in post-conviction relapse; it did not identify the earlier conviction, its sentence or the part of the term it accounted for. The Court distinguished Mailat [2026] EWHC 63 (Admin), whose warrant gave the court, date and case number of three relevant judgments, and Jipa [2024] EWHC 2785 (Admin), whose warrant expressly referred to another offence. It held that a reference to the Criminal Code, "without more, is generic" and supplied no flag inviting further inquiry (at [42]). In Smadeci (one of the four conjoined appeals in Edutanu v Iasi Court of Law [2016] EWHC 124 (Admin), [2016] 1 WLR 2933), the reference to the Code served a different purpose: the sentence related to the particularised offence alone, and the earlier offending aggravated culpability for it.
Third, the decision applies settled law. Pascariu (another of the Edutanu appeals), Presecan v Cluj-Napoca Court [2013] EWHC 1609 (Admin) and Paduche [2025] EWHC 3128 (Admin) were held not materially distinguishable, and whether there has been a wholesale failure remains a question of fact (at [5]). A fresh, properly particularised warrant may yet be issued (at [46]).
In practice, where a sentence absorbs earlier convictions that the warrant does not particularise, a generic reference to a relapse provision will not cure the defect, and validity ought not to be conceded.
Matei Clej of Outline Chambers appeared for the Appellant, instructed by AM International Solicitors. Enquiries: clerks@outlinechambers.com



Comments